Unfair Dismissal - investigate the matter or else

Investigate thoroughly or get an Unfair Dismissal Claim

A recent employment law case has highlighted the fact that, no matter how unlikely an employee's explanation for their misconduct might seem, it must still be investigated thoroughly in order to avoid a later finding of unfair dismissal.

Mr Dickson had been employed by his local city council for 28 years. His manager received a complaint from members of a youth group who visited the computer room in the school where Mr Dickson worked. They saw him accessing pornography. Two days after the complaint was made, Mr Dickson was suspended and an internal investigation commenced.

Mr Dickson stated that he had no recollection of the alleged event. He explained that, if the incident had happened, then it must have been as a result of a hypoglycaemic episode brought on by his diabetes.

During such an episode, diabetics can apparently behave quite out of character. The also may have no recollection of their actions after the episode has passed.

At the time of the event, Mr Dickson's diabetes was not well controlled. Shortly after the incident, he had to have three toes amputated as a result of his condition, and he discovered that his insulin prescription was incorrect. He also had a note from his occupational health doctor which actually suggested this as an explanation for his behaviour.

At his disciplinary hearing, however, Mr Dickson's manager gave no credibility to this explanation, and Mr Dickson was consequently sacked. He then made a claim for unfair dismissal, which he won - the council appealed, and the case was heard by an Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT).

The EAT agreed with the original tribunal's decision that the manager did not have reasonable grounds for believing that Mr Dickson was guilty of the misconduct charge. His explanation had been plausible, but had not been taken seriously.

The EAT ruled that: "scepticism is one thing, and a refusal to seriously consider the explanation proffered is another". Rather than rejecting the explanation out of hand, the manager should have consulted someone who knows more about the condition than he did such as a specialist doctor in this area.

Latest News

Three Years running - Insurance Brokerage of the Year 1 to 5 staff

Mandy and Robert Cooper were extremely honoured and astounded to once again win, Insurance Brokerage of the Year for 2020 from Insurance Business Australia magazine. This is the third year running.

While this year has not been the easiest of years for the business with Covid 19, the Recession, the hard market and issues at Lloyds of London, we are literally all in this together as an Insurance Industry.

CPR Insurance Services continues to make our clients the number one focus of our business while managing our relationships with Insurers, who we need more than ever in this market climate.

CPR Insurance Services are a highly ethical Brokerage with a reputation as a trusted advisor who always acts in the Client's best interests. Their experience, knowledge and expertise is amongst the highest in the industry.

CPR Insurance Services is now ten years old as a business and is proud of being an Authorised Representative of Ausure and their partnership with Steadfast, giving CPR the strength and backing to match it with any Broking firm in the Insurance Industry, but remain focussed on supporting the Small to Medium business segment.

Memberships of the National Insurance Brokers Association, Australia and New Zealand Institute of Insurance and Finance, Australian Insurance Law Association, Australian Professional Indemnity Group and the Australian Institute of Company Directors, ensures CPR Insurance Services maintains the high standard of knowledge and expertise required to be one of the best Brokerages in Australia.

CPR Insurance Services also plays a strong role in their local community supporting other Sporting Clubs and Community organisations. They also support and promote local businesses with their operation of the Kedron Brook Business Group who meet regularly and has 174 members.

We are truly honoured to receive this National award once again for the third year as a recognition of CPR Insurance Services contribution.

read more

Finalist for QLD Broker of the Year

Robert Cooper was honoured to be nominated as a finalist for Queensland Insurance Broker of the year for 2020, as part of the National Insurance Brokers Association. Unfortunately he missed out on the ultimate award but is a reflection of the high standard that the industry now has for such awards.

read more