Professional Indemnity FAQ

Medical Malpractice - Loss of Chance claims

Tabet v Gett [2010] HCA 12 Medical Malpractice Loss of a chance claims - Are they now gone?

The legal uncertainty from the 2004 New South Wales Court of Appeal decision in Rufo v Hosking[1] has ended. In an unanimous decision, the High Court of Australia has held in Tabet v Gett that damages are not available for the loss of a chance of a better medical outcome unless the plaintiff can prove, on the balance of probabilities, that he or she would have had a better outcome had the defendant not been negligent.

A six year old girl named Reema Tabet was admitted to hospital in 1991 after recovering from chickenpox. She was suffering headaches and nausea, and was vomiting. Dr Maurice Gett, a paediatrician made a provisional diagnosis of post-chickenpox viral encephalitis. Unfortunately, Reema later suffered a rapid deterioration in her neurological condition and had a seizure. A CT scan revealed a brain tumour (that had been growing for 2 years). Reema underwent surgery to remove part of the tumour but was subsequently diagnosed as having suffered irreversible brain damage. The expert evidence that Reema adduced at trial supported a finding that Dr Gett should have arranged for her to have a CT scan before her condition had deteriorated. Gett appealed.

After reviewing the expert evidence, the Court of Appeal held that Reema's loss of a chance of a better outcome ranged between 'speculative' and 'some'. It ultimately settled on a finding that Reema had lost only a 15% chance (as opposed to the trial judge's 40%) of avoiding the brain damage she complained of. This being the case, the Court of Appeal concluded that Reema had not proven on the balance of probabilities that she had suffered any brain damage as a result of Dr Gett's breach of duty to her.

The question at the centre of Reema's appeal to the High Court was whether the common law of Australia should recognise that the loss of a chance of a better medical outcome is actionable in damages. After considering the central question, the development of the common law in other countries and the expert evidence led at trial, the High Court dismissed Reema's appeal.

Loss of chance claims in medical negligence litigation appear now to be a thing of the past. Plaintiffs should now only be awarded damages for the loss of a proven better outcome, not a percentage of that loss based on the probability (or improbability) of the outcome occurring. This return to a balanced law will be of comfort not only to medical indemnity insurers, but also to the medical profession working in an already financially-strained healthcare system, which has limited capacity to manage 'defensive medicine'.

Latest News

Robert Cooper - one of 100 faces of small business

This week it was announced as part of Small Business Week,  that Robert has been named one of the 100 faces of small business for a State Government promotion on the great value that small businesses play in the State of Queensland.

You can see Robert's entry here:

It is the third accolade for CPR Insurance Services in a month and after seven and a half years in business is a real pep up for the company.

For Robert, it is the culmination of many years experience, becoming well qualified, experiencing the highs and lows of a career and always wanting to contribute to his community. Sometimes, these things just come together and you receive recognition for your efforts.

Robert says that there is no doubt that starting your own business is a huge challenge, but with the right research and planning, the right people around you and a good set of values that you apply to the vision of the company, you have a very good chance of making it all succeed.

Robert says he is lucky. He has a strong supportive Wife, Mandy, who is also part of the business, along with efficient and hard working staff such as Julia McLauchlan and Aidan Harmer who are building up their own skills in a learning environment. 

However, the most important and most supportive people for CPR Insurance Services are our clients who have stuck by us and supported us over the past seven years. Our focus remains on providing the best possible service we can and always acting in their best interests. To all our clients, we say thank you!

read more

CPR Insurance wins Brokerage of the year

CPR Insurance Services picked up the award for the Best Brokerage (1-5 staff) in Australia, last Friday Night (4th May 2018) at the Insurance Business Magazine Awards held at the Westin in Sydney.

Judging came from various parts of the industry. It is a great honour to be recognised for our hard work and particular Business values we follow. A full list of winners is listed here.

Success comes from having great staff, and we thank Aidan Harmer and Julia McLauchlan as important support staff for helping us win such an award.

CPR Insurance has been in operation for more than 7 years now and is only successful because of the wonderful support from our staff, insurers and most importantly, our fantastic clients who put their faith and trust into our company to be their Risk Advisers and Brokers. 

Thank you to all.

read more