Professional Indemnity FAQ

Professional Risks that come with Premium Funding

Professional Risks that come with Premium Funding

For many of us Insurance Brokers, we have probably taken for granted our own professional exposure when it comes to arranging Premium Funding for our clients.

For the uninitiated, premium funding is what we call when a short term loan is arranged from a finance company to pay insurers the premium, but repayments are made monthly (usually ten months but no more than a year) back to the financier. Simply the Insurance policy is the security. If they default on the repayments, the policy is cancelled and any refund is returned to the premium funder/financier to pay off the outstanding amount.

But what happens if the Broker has arranged a non-cancellable policy? Is the Broker obligated to inform the Premium Funder? Afterall, sometimes a small commission is earnt for connecting the client to the Premium Funder.

It appears the High Court has determined the issue in Miller & Associates Insurance Broking Pty Ltd v BMW Australia Finance Limited [2010] HCA 31.

Briefly the facts are that Consolidated Timber Holdings Limited ('Consolidated Timber') retained an insurance broker, Miller & Associates Insurance Broking Pty Limited ('Miller'), to negotiate a $3.975 million loan with a financier, BMW Australia Finance Limited ('BMW'), on its behalf. .The cancellability of the policy in this case was not subject to any express communications between Miller and BMW.

Consolidated Timber ultimately defaulted on the loan, leaving BMW unable to recover $2.715 million of the $3.975 million borrowed. It commenced proceedings against Miller in the Victorian Supreme Court alleging, relevantly, that Miller had engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct contrary to s52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 in:

The primary judge found against BMW, but it successfully appealed to the Victorian Court of Appeal. Miller then applied to the High Court for special leave to appeal. The High Court unanimously found for Miller, overturning the Victorian Court of Appeal's decision and reinstating the decision of the primary judge.

According to the majority, the relevant circumstances in this matter were that:

  • BMW failed to make reasonable inquiries following receipt of the certificate, which put it on notice that the underlying policy may be an unusual one
  • There was nothing in the conduct of the parties to put Miller on notice that BMW was under a misapprehension that the policy was cancellable, or that cancellability was important to the determination application. In fact, BMW's requested directors' guarantees suggesting not.

The policy was not a lengthy document and apparent it was not a property policy, nor cancellable.

It was not disputed that Miller knew that the cancellability of insurance was important to a premium lender's determination of a loan application. Nevertheless, in light of the factors referred to above, the majority held that: 'There was no foundation for the conclusion that the known importance of cancellability gave rise to a reasonable expectation,With respect to the policy wording itself, the majority considered that 'Miller's failure to draw to BMW's attention a circumstance that the document itself disclosed was not misleading or deceptive.'

Similarly, Chief Justice French and Justice Kiefel noted that the knowledge of the person to whom the conduct is directed, and 'the existence of common assumptions and practices established between the parties or prevailing in the particular profession, trade or industry in which they carry on business' may be relevant in characterising conduct in commercial dealings. They concluded that '..as a general proposition, s52 does not require a party to commercial negotiations to volunteer information which will be of assistance to the decision-making of the other party. A fortiori it does not impose on a party an obligation to volunteer information in order to avoid the consequences of the careless disregard, for its own interests, of another party of equal bargaining power and competence.'

Latest News

Three Years running - Insurance Brokerage of the Year 1 to 5 staff

Mandy and Robert Cooper were extremely honoured and astounded to once again win, Insurance Brokerage of the Year for 2020 from Insurance Business Australia magazine. This is the third year running.

While this year has not been the easiest of years for the business with Covid 19, the Recession, the hard market and issues at Lloyds of London, we are literally all in this together as an Insurance Industry.

CPR Insurance Services continues to make our clients the number one focus of our business while managing our relationships with Insurers, who we need more than ever in this market climate.

CPR Insurance Services are a highly ethical Brokerage with a reputation as a trusted advisor who always acts in the Client's best interests. Their experience, knowledge and expertise is amongst the highest in the industry.

CPR Insurance Services is now ten years old as a business and is proud of being an Authorised Representative of Ausure and their partnership with Steadfast, giving CPR the strength and backing to match it with any Broking firm in the Insurance Industry, but remain focussed on supporting the Small to Medium business segment.

Memberships of the National Insurance Brokers Association, Australia and New Zealand Institute of Insurance and Finance, Australian Insurance Law Association, Australian Professional Indemnity Group and the Australian Institute of Company Directors, ensures CPR Insurance Services maintains the high standard of knowledge and expertise required to be one of the best Brokerages in Australia.

CPR Insurance Services also plays a strong role in their local community supporting other Sporting Clubs and Community organisations. They also support and promote local businesses with their operation of the Kedron Brook Business Group who meet regularly and has 174 members.

We are truly honoured to receive this National award once again for the third year as a recognition of CPR Insurance Services contribution.

read more

Finalist for QLD Broker of the Year

Robert Cooper was honoured to be nominated as a finalist for Queensland Insurance Broker of the year for 2020, as part of the National Insurance Brokers Association. Unfortunately he missed out on the ultimate award but is a reflection of the high standard that the industry now has for such awards.

read more