News

A decision in the NZ High Court prompts a need to review of Directors' & Officers' Insurance Coverages

News >> Directors and Officers Liability

This decision relates to the collapse of the Bridgecorp companies back in July 2007. It left almost 14,300 investors out of pocket by around $460 million. The New Zealand corporate regulator is currently seeking criminal charges against their company directors. As the directors had already used up the sum of $2 million available to them under a directors' statutory liability policy, they then sought to access Bridgecorp's other policy. This was a Directors & Officers Liability policy with a sum insured of $20,000,000. They wanted to fund further defence costs estimated at $3 million out of it.

However the Bridgecorp receivers had already told the D&O insurers that they intend to bring civil proceedings against the directors, and that they have first claim over the insurance. It was because of a provision in the Law Reform Act 1936 (New Zealand).

The New Zealand High Court agreed, and ruled that the directors could not access the insurance funds. This affects States such as New South Wales, Northern Territory and the Australian Capital Territory but not Queensland and Victoria.  In New South Wales, the relevant act is the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946 which was based on the New Zealand legislation and contains a similar provision. There is equivalent legislation in Northern Territory and Australian Capital Territory..

All company directors could potentially be prejudiced because the law of New South Wales may apply when interpreting their insurance policy. This is because many insurance policies are issued by insurers carrying on business in New South Wales. The laws of that State will usually apply. This is despite the fact that the policy refers to jurisdiction within all of the Commonwealth of Australia jurisdiction.

There may be an argument in the future where a company is in liquidation and  operates only in Queensland and even the liquidator is from Queensland, but the law of New South Wales applies because their insurer carries on a business there. This law may be difficult to avoid as it is designed to protect creditors from losing the benefit of the insurance monies owed by an insurer carrying on business in that State. However we really do not know if this same precedent will be followed here.

It may instead be considered better for the directors of companies who are currently insured with a New South Wales insurer to not take the risk that a court will  apply this State’s laws, and shift to an Insurer based elsewhere given the limiting of directors' rights under the D&O policy. It may be better for the Insurers instead to issue their policy from another State.

In either situation, it is worth trying to fix this potential issue. 

Read more here

Last changed: Nov 01 2011 at 12:59 PM

Comments

  1. None Found

Add Comment

Latest News

Three Years running - Insurance Brokerage of the Year 1 to 5 staff

Mandy and Robert Cooper were extremely honoured and astounded to once again win, Insurance Brokerage of the Year for 2020 from Insurance Business Australia magazine. This is the third year running.

While this year has not been the easiest of years for the business with Covid 19, the Recession, the hard market and issues at Lloyds of London, we are literally all in this together as an Insurance Industry.

CPR Insurance Services continues to make our clients the number one focus of our business while managing our relationships with Insurers, who we need more than ever in this market climate.

CPR Insurance Services are a highly ethical Brokerage with a reputation as a trusted advisor who always acts in the Client's best interests. Their experience, knowledge and expertise is amongst the highest in the industry.

CPR Insurance Services is now ten years old as a business and is proud of being an Authorised Representative of Ausure and their partnership with Steadfast, giving CPR the strength and backing to match it with any Broking firm in the Insurance Industry, but remain focussed on supporting the Small to Medium business segment.

Memberships of the National Insurance Brokers Association, Australia and New Zealand Institute of Insurance and Finance, Australian Insurance Law Association, Australian Professional Indemnity Group and the Australian Institute of Company Directors, ensures CPR Insurance Services maintains the high standard of knowledge and expertise required to be one of the best Brokerages in Australia.

CPR Insurance Services also plays a strong role in their local community supporting other Sporting Clubs and Community organisations. They also support and promote local businesses with their operation of the Kedron Brook Business Group who meet regularly and has 174 members.

We are truly honoured to receive this National award once again for the third year as a recognition of CPR Insurance Services contribution.

read more

Finalist for QLD Broker of the Year

Robert Cooper was honoured to be nominated as a finalist for Queensland Insurance Broker of the year for 2020, as part of the National Insurance Brokers Association. Unfortunately he missed out on the ultimate award but is a reflection of the high standard that the industry now has for such awards.

read more